Presidency Clarifies Tinubu Is Not Facing Criminal Case in US
The Presidency has clarified that President Bola Ahmed Tinubu is not facing a criminal case in the United States, saying the ongoing court proceedings involving records connected to the Nigerian leader are part of a civil Freedom of Information Act dispute. The clarification was issued by Bayo Onanuga, Special Adviser to the President on Information and Strategy, following renewed reports and political commentary surrounding the case. The Presidency said the proceedings before the United States District Court for the District of Columbia concern requests for the release of government records and the legality of redactions made by US agencies.
Onanuga said the case does not amount to a criminal charge or trial against Tinubu and stressed that no US court has found the President guilty of criminal wrongdoing. “For clarity, the matter is a civil records-disclosure dispute under the United States Freedom of Information Act. It is not a criminal case against President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, nor has the court found him guilty of any criminal wrongdoing,” the Presidency stated.
How the Case Began
According to the Presidency, the matter dates back to 2022, when Aaron Greenspan submitted Freedom of Information Act requests to several US government agencies seeking records relating to Tinubu. The agencies either withheld certain records or declined to confirm or deny whether some requested records existed. Greenspan subsequently commenced Civil Action No.
23-1816 before the US District Court for the District of Columbia in 2023. Tinubu was later permitted by the court to participate in the proceedings as an intervenor. His participation means that he has a legal interest in issues concerning the requested records, but it does not mean that he has been charged with a criminal offence in the case.
The US Department of Justice's own Office of Information Policy identifies the matter as Greenspan v. EOUSA, No. 23-1816.
A 2025 court decision dealt with Freedom of Information Act exemptions and whether agencies could maintain so-called "Glomar" responses concerning requested records. FBI and DEA Records at Centre of Dispute
The current controversy centres largely on records held by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Drug Enforcement Administration. The Presidency said the agencies have produced records containing redactions, while the remaining dispute concerns whether those redactions and any withholding of information are lawful under the US Freedom of Information Act.
A Glomar response is a mechanism under US freedom of information law through which an agency can decline to confirm or deny the existence of certain records when acknowledging their existence could itself reveal information protected by an exemption. The Presidency said the use of such mechanisms should not be interpreted as evidence that an individual has been found guilty of a crime. It stressed that the central legal question in the current proceedings is access to government records and the application of statutory exemptions.
Presidency References 2003 US Consulate Letter
In its latest statement, the Presidency also referred to a February 4, 2003 letter from the US Consulate in Lagos to Nigeria's then Inspector General of Police, Tafa Balogun. According to the Presidency, the letter stated that an FBI records check had found no criminal arrest records or warrants for Tinubu, who was serving as governor of Lagos State at the time. The Presidency cited the document as part of its argument concerning the historical records surrounding the President.
However, recent US court filings and reporting have continued to generate public discussion about historical investigations and records involving Tinubu. The existence of records concerning an investigation does not, by itself, establish that the person named in those records committed a crime. Anadolu Agency, reporting on the court documents, similarly noted that the records did not establish criminal wrongdoing by Tinubu and that his legal team was challenging further disclosure of some information.
Court Has Already Ruled on Some Agencies
The Presidency said the US District Court previously granted summary judgment in favour of several government entities, including the CIA, the Executive Office for United States Attorneys, the Department of State, the Department of the Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service. Those developments reduced the number of issues and agencies remaining in the litigation. The outstanding dispute now includes questions surrounding records and redactions involving the FBI and DEA.
The Presidency said the plaintiff has until September 11, 2026, to file an opposition and reply to processes filed by the defendants and Tinubu as an intervenor. It added that the FBI, DEA and Tinubu would have until September 18 to respond to any processes filed by the plaintiff. Presidency Rejects Political Interpretation
The clarification comes amid intense political debate in Nigeria, with opposition figures and other political actors discussing the US proceedings and Tinubu's history in the United States.
The Presidency accused some commentators of portraying the FOIA litigation as though it were a fresh criminal prosecution against the President. Onanuga also rejected recent commentary by Karl von Batten, saying that neither von Batten nor his client is a party to the case. The Presidency maintained that the eventual decision belongs to the US court and will be determined by the evidence, applicable law and arguments presented by the parties.
The distinction between a criminal case and a FOIA case is important. A criminal prosecution seeks to establish whether a person committed an offence and can result in criminal penalties if the accused is convicted. A FOIA lawsuit, by contrast, concerns access to government records and whether an agency has properly applied exemptions allowing it to withhold or redact information.
The Presidency therefore urged the Nigerian media and the public to distinguish between the actual court proceedings and political commentary surrounding them. For now, the US litigation remains ongoing. The court has not issued a criminal conviction against Tinubu in the matter, and the outstanding legal questions concern the disclosure and redaction of government records.
The case is being handled by Judge Beryl A. Howell of the US District Court for the District of Columbia, who will determine the remaining issues under US law.