Blog Detail
SERAP Asks Appeal Court to Overturn N100m DSS Defamation Award

NaijaTalk

|

2026-10-08

SERAP Asks Appeal Court to Overturn N100m DSS Defamation Award

The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) has asked the Court of Appeal in Abuja to overturn a N100 million defamation judgment awarded against the organisation in a case involving two officers of the Department of State Services (DSS). The appeal is scheduled for hearing on Friday and challenges the judgment delivered by Justice Yusuf Halilu of the Federal Capital Territory High Court on May 5, 2026. The case is registered as CA/ABJ/CV/1114/2026.
The lower court had awarded N100 million in damages against SERAP in favour of DSS officers Sarah John and Gabriel Ogundele. It also ordered SERAP to pay N1 million in litigation costs and directed the organisation to publish a public apology on its website and X account, as well as in two national newspapers and two television stations. The judgment further provided for 10 per cent annual interest on the damages until the debt is fully paid.
The dispute arose from publications made by SERAP on September 9, 2024, concerning an alleged visit by DSS operatives to the organisation's Abuja office. SERAP had alleged that the officers unlawfully entered its premises following the organisation's call for an investigation into allegations of corruption at the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited and its criticism of fuel price increases. The publications did not identify the two DSS officers by name.
Instead, they contained physical descriptions, including references to a tall, large, dark-skinned woman and a slim, dark-skinned man. The officers subsequently instituted the defamation action, arguing that the publications referred to them and damaged their reputations. In its appeal, SERAP is challenging the finding that the publications sufficiently identified the two officers.
The organisation's legal team, led by Senior Advocate of Nigeria Tayo Oyetibo, argued in its Appellant's Brief dated September 3 that the publications did not mention the officers by name, rank, designation, office or photograph. SERAP said the descriptions relied upon by the DSS officers were general physical descriptions and were not enough, without additional evidence, to establish that reasonable readers would understand the publications to refer specifically to the two claimants. The organisation also challenged the trial judge's reliance on his own observation of the physical appearance of the respondents in court.
SERAP argued that the relevant question was whether the publications identified the officers when they were published, rather than whether the officers matched the descriptions when they appeared before the judge. SERAP's appeal contains 24 grounds challenging the finding of liability, the damages awarded and the consequential orders made by the FCT High Court. The organisation is also challenging the evidence relied upon by the trial court and the extent to which the DSS officers established reputational, professional or financial injury arising from the publications.
Another issue raised by SERAP concerns the original filing of the lawsuit. The organisation argued that the case was initially filed against "Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project", which it described as a non-juristic entity, before the plaintiffs later amended the originating process to substitute it with the Incorporated Trustees of SERAP. The organisation maintains that the initial defect was fundamental and could not simply be corrected through an amendment.
It is asking the Court of Appeal to consider whether the trial court was right to allow the proceedings to continue after the amendment. SERAP has also questioned the validity of one of the witness statements relied upon in the case. According to its appeal, the statement was allegedly signed at the witness's lawyers' chambers rather than before a Commissioner for Oaths.
SERAP argues that the subsequent adoption of the statement in court could not cure what it considers a fundamental defect in the manner in which the statement was sworn. On the substance of the publications, SERAP maintains that they should have been considered within their full context rather than by isolating expressions such as "invasion", "harassment", "intimidation" and "unlawful". The organisation argues that the publications concerned the conduct of security officials during a visit to its office and amounted to commentary on a matter of legitimate public interest.
SERAP further argues that its publications were protected by constitutional freedom of expression and that the organisation had established a factual basis for its account of the incident. It maintains that disagreement by the DSS officers with its description of the events did not, by itself, establish defamation or malice.
reference: https://www.thecable.ng/seraps-appeal-against-n100m-damages-award-to-dss-officers-for-hearing-friday/

Subscribe To Get Updates on Our Latest Blog Post

No credit card required

0 Comments

No comments yet.

Leave Your Comment

You may also like

No related posts available